Appeals and Challenges

If you have received a negative decision for your immigration or asylum application, there may be options available to appeal the Home Office’s decision.

Our experienced team of immigration lawyers can help you understand the decision and provide honest and accurate advice on the options available to challenge it.

How to appeal or challenge a Home Office decision

Most Home Office decisions can be challenged in some way. The type of legal challenge to be raised in each case will depend on the type of application that was made.


An appeal is a legal challenge to the merits of a Home Office decision. This involves asking a specialist court, known as the First Tier Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber), to consider the evidence and law in your case to determine whether the Home Office has made the correct decision in law and in fact. The case will be heard by an Immigration Judge with knowledge of UK immigration and asylum law. 

Not all Home Office decisions come with a right of appeal. You can usually appeal a decision from the Home Office in the following circumstances:

In some cases, the Home Office may determine an application as clearly unfounded, indicating that it lacks legal or factual basis and is bound to fail. In such instances, the application may be certified as clearly unfounded, resulting in the removal of the usual right of appeal. However, it may still be possible to challenge the certification through a judicial review.

A successful appeal results in an Immigration Judge granting the appellant permission to enter or remain in the UK, either as originally requested or through an alternative type of leave proposed during the appeal.

If an appeal is refused, there is the option to raise a further appeal to the Upper Tribunal to argue that the First Tier Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) made legal errors.

Judicial Review 

A judicial review is different from an appeal as it does not assess the merits of an application and is generally not focused on whether the decision was right. Instead, it challenges whether proper process and procedures were followed. It is commonly used to challenge Home Office decisions in immigration and asylum cases, and in some cases, decisions of a higher court or tribunal. Judicial review is a recourse when no other Home Office appeal options exist.

Examples of decisions amenable to judicial review include cases where:

If a judicial review application succeeds, the original decision is not replaced, but the Home Office (or Upper Tribunal) will be asked to remake the decision using proper procedures. This means they may reach the same outcome, but with the appropriate process and consideration of all relevant information.

For removal cases, a judicial review can result in an injunction (or interim order in Scotland) preventing removal for a specific period.

If a judicial review fails, it means the judge deemed the Home Office decision to be proper. In some cases, judicial review decisions can be appealed to a higher court.

Administrative Review 

Administrative review asks the Home Office to consider whether an eligible immigration decision was made incorrectly due to a case working error. Examples include applying the wrong immigration rule, applying the immigration rules incorrectly, or failing to consider all relevant evidence or failing to apply published guidance. 

Various visa decisions are eligible for administrative review, such as visitor visas (without human rights issues), student visas, skilled worker visas, and Hong Kong British National (Overseas) applications.

If a case working error is identified, it will be corrected. This may result in overturning the original decision or solely rectifying the error without a change to the substance of the decision. Highly individual and tailored legal representations are essential for a successful administrative review.

If an administrative review fails, the original refusal stands. The decision may then be challenged through judicial review.

We’re here to help you

When it comes to obtaining reliable legal advice, Seraphus is your dedicated source of expert guidance.

We specialise in providing personalised support to help you navigate the complexities of the application process, ensuring a seamless and hassle-free experience.

Contact us today using the details below or book a consultation with us.

Phone: 020 8142 8211

WhatsApp: 07538 208 096



All Personal Immigration Services:

Our customers rate us highly on Trustpilot

  • "I'm dealing with a stressful immigration issue but after speaking with Christopher Benn, I've become very hopeful. He's dedicated, supportive and very knowledgeable, unlike some unscrupulous immigration solicitors. The service exceeded my expectations. I strongly recommend Seraphus Solicitors to anyone seeking legal assistance with immigration issues."


  • "I am so grateful to Anna who handled my case, right from the beginning she was very easy going and gave all the advice I needed, I will advise anyone planning to use them, to have the full service, don't just seek advice, but also let them fully handle the case."