New ILR Rules: There is nothing fair about a 10-year wait
Written by: Caroline Echwald
The Home Secretary, Shabana Mahmood has confirmed that “earned settlement” will go ahead. As described in our overview of the new indefinite leave to remain (ILR) rules, many people will wait 10 years for ILR instead of 5, and some will wait 20 or even 30 years. These changes will apply to people already living, working and raising families in the UK.
At Seraphus, we strongly condemn this decision. These plans have nothing to do with ensuring fairness and contribution. In practice, they will leave people poorer, more insecure and, in the end, more likely to need help from the state, not less.
Why the ILR 10-year route may not save public money
In A Fairer Pathway to Settlement the government argues that longer routes will protect the public finances. But making people wait does not stop most of them settling, it only delays the cost. The government’s own consultation expected around 1.4 million settlement grants between 2026 and 2030.
What the ILR 10-year route will do is hold people back. With ILR, people can change jobs freely, take better-paid work (as the government’s own analysis accepts), start a business or more easily buy a home. On temporary visas, such as the Skilled Worker visa, they stay tied to a sponsor or the next visa decision, usually without a safety net if things go wrong. Accessing public funds in the five years before applying for ILR will potentially push applicants onto an even longer 20-year route. That means when a family needs support, the pressure is moved to councils, schools, health services and charities.
The burden falls hardest on those who earn least. People earning at least £125,141 can settle in 3 years. Those earning from £12,571 to £50,270 will usually wait 10. For comparison, the median full-time wage in the UK in 2026 is just over £40,000.
The real cost of the new ILR rules
Migrants already pay heavily for the right to stay in the UK:
• £1,035 a year for most adults for the NHS through the Immigration Health Surcharge, on top of the same tax and National Insurance everyone else pays.
- • Up to £1,865 in fees every time a visa is renewed.
- • £3,226 to apply for ILR.
- Over 10 years, that adds up to more than £16,000 for one person. If you have a partner or children, they must also pay.
Last year, an investigation found the government made almost £5 billion in profit from the immigration system. This money does not build a future. It cannot go towards a home, savings, a child’s education or a business. It is simply the price of being allowed to stay. And under earned settlement, the lowest earners will pay it for longest.
How the ILR changes affect people already here
The cost is not only financial. Many people have spent most of their lives in the UK on temporary visas trying to build up time to settle permanently. When rules change, so do the circumstances of those who have just found a path to settle after years of uncertainty.
This is the case for one of our clients. They recently got permission to stay under the private life route after 20 years living in the UK. Under the current rules, they would now start their 10-year residence to achieve settlement/indefinite leave to remain. This would mean 30 years in total before getting settlement.
Because of their personal circumstances, they had a period of overstaying. Under the current rules, this would normally be disregarded because of their long residence in the UK. Under earned settlement, it will not be, and they may not qualify for ILR for another 20 years, making this a 40 year wait.
Settlement should not be a reward for the wealthy. It is the foundation that lets people build a stable life and participate fully in the UK. A fair system would make it easier to reach, not harder.
Find out more and take action
Sign the petition against making the changes apply retrospectively.
Many organisations share our concerns. Here is what they are saying and how you can get involved.
- Sign refugees’ petition against the new rules with Asylum Matters.
- Read the Disability Rights UK Statement on earned settlement and how it reduces the rights of disabled migrants.
- Join the waitlist for the Right to Remain online meeting responding to earned settlement on 19 November 2026.
- Read Greater Manchester Immigration Aid Unit earned settlement explainer.
- Electronic Immigration Network show how migrant and refugee groups have responded.
Worried about how earned settlement affects you?
Contact our immigration team for advice.
Read more about ILR
-
What Is Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR) and What Does It Mean?
Written by: Aarshi Joshi
What does ILR mean? Very simply, ILR means indefinite leave to remain in the UK. If you hold indefinite leave to remain it gives you the right to live in the UK permanently. You may have heard indefinite leave to remain referred to as permanent residence in the UK. Both terms are used interchangeably, however […]Read article -
The impact of absences on ILR applications
Written by: Christopher Desira
If you are working towards your Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR) UK immigration status, you may already know that time spent outside the UK—even for a holiday or a business trip—might affect your ILR eligibility. The qualifying period for ILR (often 5 years but sometimes 10, depending on your route) requires a certain amount of […]Read article -
Indefinite Leave to Remain vs British citizenship: which is the better choice for long-term UK residents
Written by: Christopher Desira
Understand how to decide between indefinite leave to remain and British Citizenship in 2026. For many long-term residents the choice between indefinite leave to remain (also known as ‘ILR’ or ‘settlement’) and British citizenship is crucial. At Seraphus, we understand the uncertainties of immigration statuses. This guide explains the differences, highlights the benefits and limitations of […]Read article

Personal Immigration Service
We offer a range of services suited to your personal immigration situation, including preparing and submitting visa applications, immigration reviews or representing you in your appeal or challenge of a refusal decision.

Application Checks
Need help checking an immigration application? We’ll make sure it’s thoroughly reviewed, and you are provided written feedback so you can perfect your application.
£750 + VAT 5-10 working days

Video Consultation
Get a one-off assessment of your situation and receive advice on next steps.
£199 + VAT 30 min
Categories: Immigration News